possibly I observe too many TCM films (can just one ever look at a lot of basic movies?) but these lovely 4″ black Mach & Mach Diamond of Elizabeth Imitation Pearl Pointed Toe Pumps remind me of the shoe we would've https://www.aquarius-brand.com/collections/heels-pumps/products/black-square-toe-cap-w-pencil-heel-tie-up-strap